Morning, my friend is an hgv driver and has worked with his present company for 26 years. He had his medical last year without any concerns being flagged up. Suddenly out of the blue he received a letter informing him that his licences have been suspended due to alcohol dependency. I know there will be a few posters who will reply that abstinence is the only way and that drink driving is the act of the devil but before you send that reply bear in mind he takes his responsibilities seriously and doesn’t drink before he has to work and he has never failed any medical or breath tests and has no convictions. His bosses are behind him because of his unblemished record so what does he need to do to clear this up promptly? This seems to me that someone has become lawman , judge , jury and punisher without evidence.
Alcohol dependence
Collapse
Loading...
X
-
Hi Meellis,
No judgment but do need a little more info about the reason for withdrawal of his licence. You mention his work medical last year was this long ago and do the company performing the medical have access to your friend's medical records (which he would have had to consent to).
Has he had annual medicals for years? Is this the first time his dependency has been mentioned or were they aware before this most recent check? Is this the first time he has mentioned any dependency?
Is it a new company carrying out the medicals? It appears that there is a blanket reporting criteria for drug and alcohol dependencies? Has something happened that has brought the dependency to the fore recently?
I have found the following which dictates medical professionals duties where they come across alcohol dependency situations and the individual holds an HGV licence. It may be something as simple as once the medical person who performed the medical was aware of the diagnosis they are legally obliged to act informing DVLA. So maybe not judge and jury but legal obligation I'm afraid.
Here is the gov't site explaining the duties of medical professionals when they are aware of alcohol and drug dependence. The rules would appear stricter where HGV licences and buses are concerned: https://www.gov.uk/guidance/drug-or-...tness-to-driveI am a qualified solicitor and am happy to try and assist informally, where needed.
Any posts I make on LegalBeagles are for information and discussion purposes only and shouldn't be seen as legal advice. Any practical advice I give is without liability. I do not represent people on the forum.
If in doubt you should always seek professional face to face legal advice.
- 1 thank
-
Thanks Peridot, The medical he had last summer was for his hgv renewal and there was nothing noted. He went to see his doctor yesterday with the letter and the doctor has signed him off sick for a week to buy some time so it doesn't sound like the doctor had any concerns, his bosses are totally behind him so they don't sound as though they have had any concerns. The letter has just come completely out of the blue and doesn't really explain much, you would have thought that they would have to produce the reason why they have been bound to serve this penalty.
Comment
-
Problem is that anyone can report a driver to the DVLA directly and anonymously.
The DVLA will then take precautionary measures to protect the public, and the unfortunate driver then has to(figuratively) jump through hoops backwards to regain his licence.
One of my friends was reported anonymously for suffering from blackouts. He didn't but he still had his licence revoked for about 3 months before he could get it back.
- 1 thank
Comment
-
Thanks for the replies, even though I understand why they would be cautionary (DVLA) I still feel it is off. The village where we live hasn't the greatest transport links, like most villages, so now he has to find a way to and from work in a town 15 miles away. He starts at 4 in the morning by the way so it wouldn't matter how good transport was. I am sure the insurance companies will pound him now if he gets his licence sorted and the company he works for will have to work around him or I suppose an employed driver without a licence is a bloke looking for a new job. You wold have thought random testing while investigating the allegations would have been more in keeping with innocent until proven guilty. I think, like credit reference agencies and the like, some pen pushers take to lightly how they can destroy someone's life.
Comment
-
Originally posted by des8 View PostProblem is that anyone can report a driver to the DVLA directly and anonymously.
The DVLA will then take precautionary measures to protect the public, and the unfortunate driver then has to(figuratively) jump through hoops backwards to regain his licence.
One of my friends was reported anonymously for suffering from blackouts. He didn't but he still had his licence revoked for about 3 months before he could get it back.
Comment
-
It may seem harsh but the ramifications for those who do not report and then something awful happens would be just as disastrous for them professionally too. Unfortunately it affects those who would not be an issue but where do you draw the line?I am a qualified solicitor and am happy to try and assist informally, where needed.
Any posts I make on LegalBeagles are for information and discussion purposes only and shouldn't be seen as legal advice. Any practical advice I give is without liability. I do not represent people on the forum.
If in doubt you should always seek professional face to face legal advice.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Peridot View PostIt may seem harsh but the ramifications for those who do not report and then something awful happens would be just as disastrous for them professionally too. Unfortunately it affects those who would not be an issue but where do you draw the line?
If something awful happens then there is a justice system that's tried and tested to deal with the offender.
Comment
-
When he went through his medical was anything disclosed on there that could have led to the decision ? Did he keep a copy ? If not I think he needs to be asking for a copy and asking the DVLA for details of their decision. Even if the Doctor had no concerned I think there's a question about how many units of alcohol per week and the DVLA's view on what's 'misuse' or 'dependency' seems to differ from a Doctors view - it's likely to have been when the form was reviewed by the DVLA that the revocation decision was made.#staysafestayhome
Any support I provide is offered without liability, if you are unsure please seek professional legal guidance.
Received a Court Claim? Read >>>>> First Steps
Comment
-
Originally posted by Jinxer View Post
If something awful happens then there is a justice system that's tried and tested to deal with the offender.
It's a difficult situation especially given that the subject drives for a living and I would advise that he asks his docter to write to DVLA with their view as to his suitability to drive.
- 1 thank
Comment
-
Turns out it seems he has been punished for being honest. Amethyst it is down to the units of alcohol question, he answered honestly last summer. Two months after his HGV licence was revoked and now, four months after they have decided to revoke his car licence. Even though I understand the need for caution on behalf of the DVLA my understanding is that he hasn't actually broken any laws like being caught driving while under the influence just some guidelines.So being honest about having a social drink outside of work is worse than lying and saying you don't drink at all.
- 2 likes
Comment
-
Any idea what he entered / said as Units ? Saw someone else mention 30 a week resulting in removal but I think the tipping point is 14 ( nhs guidance ). 14 is 6 pints. 30 is what 12/13 pints... so a couple a night , or one a night and a session on a Sunday afternoon for example .... not exactly alcohol dependency.#staysafestayhome
Any support I provide is offered without liability, if you are unsure please seek professional legal guidance.
Received a Court Claim? Read >>>>> First Steps
Comment
-
The D4 form doesn't seem to ask the alcohol question so may have been in conversation with the doctor or elsewhere in medical notes ( as Jules just said if any injuries presented at hosp were due to inebriation ) He's having a look into it a bit more anyway ( as he's an hgv Driver too and has these medicals too he likely knows more than me )#staysafestayhome
Any support I provide is offered without liability, if you are unsure please seek professional legal guidance.
Received a Court Claim? Read >>>>> First Steps
Comment
-
Doctors guidance https://assets.publishing.service.go...fessionals.pdf#staysafestayhome
Any support I provide is offered without liability, if you are unsure please seek professional legal guidance.
Received a Court Claim? Read >>>>> First Steps
Comment
View our Terms and Conditions
LegalBeagles Group uses cookies to enhance your browsing experience and to create a secure and effective website. By using this website, you are consenting to such use.To find out more and learn how to manage cookies please read our Cookie and Privacy Policy.
If you would like to opt in, or out, of receiving news and marketing from LegalBeagles Group Ltd you can amend your settings at any time here.
If you would like to cancel your registration please Contact Us. We will delete your user details on request, however, any previously posted user content will remain on the site with your username removed and 'Guest' inserted.
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Court Claim ?
Guides and LettersSHORTCUTS
Pre-Action Letters
First Steps
Check dates
Income/Expenditure
Acknowledge Claim
CCA Request
CPR 31.14 Request
Subject Access Request Letter
Example Defence
Set Aside Application
Witness Statements
Directions Questionnaire
Statute Barred Letter
Voluntary Termination: Letter Templates
A guide to voluntary termination: Your rights
Loading...
Loading...
Comment