The downstairs neighbour of a flat I own has taken me to small claims court for the cost of repairs to their kitchen ceiling which they claim were needed due to a leak from my property. There was no evidence of a leak that my contractor found in my property although we did get the bath resealed as a precaution, and this neighbour had previously mentioned that there were issues with the kitchen ceiling due to a previous leak from my property prior to me owning it.
I said as a gesture of good will that I would contribute towards the excess of their insurance claim to get the work done, however, the neighbour said they wouldn't go through insurance as they'd lose their no claims bonus. I told them I would not pay towards the cost of them getting their kitchen ceiling re-plastered in this case (all documented in letter form). They have previously demanded I pay for 'repairs' for other issues in their property (i.e. cracks in their ceilings which I would say are due to age and nothing to do with me or anything my tenants have done).
I'm not really sure what to put in my draft defence as I never received the court paperwork to begin with and only found out when I found a default CCJ on my credit file. The example in the Leagle Beagles guide starts with an admittance that there was a contract, but I never agreed to pay for anything. I've received particulars from the court but they literally just say the claimant is saying I owe an amount of money (which matches what they demanded to have the kitchen ceiling re-plastered). I have already sent a consent to set aside to the neighbour as they sent the paperwork to the property which they know I don't live at, but I don't expect them to grant it. Any assistance would be much appreciated.
Thanks
I said as a gesture of good will that I would contribute towards the excess of their insurance claim to get the work done, however, the neighbour said they wouldn't go through insurance as they'd lose their no claims bonus. I told them I would not pay towards the cost of them getting their kitchen ceiling re-plastered in this case (all documented in letter form). They have previously demanded I pay for 'repairs' for other issues in their property (i.e. cracks in their ceilings which I would say are due to age and nothing to do with me or anything my tenants have done).
I'm not really sure what to put in my draft defence as I never received the court paperwork to begin with and only found out when I found a default CCJ on my credit file. The example in the Leagle Beagles guide starts with an admittance that there was a contract, but I never agreed to pay for anything. I've received particulars from the court but they literally just say the claimant is saying I owe an amount of money (which matches what they demanded to have the kitchen ceiling re-plastered). I have already sent a consent to set aside to the neighbour as they sent the paperwork to the property which they know I don't live at, but I don't expect them to grant it. Any assistance would be much appreciated.
Thanks
Comment