• Welcome to the LegalBeagles Consumer and Legal Forum.
    Please Register to get the most out of the forum. Registration is free and only needs a username and email address.
    REGISTER
    Please do not post your full name, reference numbers or any identifiable details on the forum.

Should I reply to defence?

Collapse
Loading...
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Should I reply to defence?

    Hi all, to briefly summarise my case. I initiated action against an individual for unpaid wages for a job done awhile back. This person is defending the claim in full saying that I was contracted through his limited company. In essence he is denying liability.

    I was just wondering in this instance is a reply to his defence merited? In our communications prior to the job he never said he was acting as a director of a company nor did he include statutory required information about any company in his communications with me which would be a breach of reg 24 of SI 2005/17. Can I bring this up in my reply?

    Is it true I can't quote legislation or breaches to regulations in my Witness statement so the reply would be only possible place. My particulars of claim was quite brief.
    Tags: None

  • #2
    Yes, you can raise those points.

    Witness statements are for setting out facts. You make your legal arguments at the hearing.
    Lawyer (solicitor) - retired from practice, now in academia. I do not advise by private message.

    Litigants in Person should download and read this: https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/..._in_Person.pdf

    Comment


    • #3
      Many thanks for your reply. I am not the best orator so I am quite fearful at the prospect of a hearing.

      I mentioned in my particulars of claim that the defendant paid me for part of the job. He didn't address this in his reply. Is there any significance of him failing to address that?

      Could I expand further on that point in my reply to his defence? (that he deducted tax from my pay and didn't pay the HMRC on my behalf) Or would that be suitable for the witness statement?

      Comment


      • #4
        Does anyone know whether there is a form for replying to the defence or can I write a reply on a blank piece of paper and submit it with my directions questionnaire?

        Comment


        • #5
          I noticed a mistake in my initial post. I meant to say breached SI 2015/17.

          Comment


          • #6
            Please read constructionblog.practicallaw.com/the-limits-of-a-reply

            The article explains what you can and can't write in a reply to defence.

            The front page should state the case no. the county court name,. the Claimant, the Defendant and headed Reply to Defence

            Paragraphs should be numbered with numbers corresponding to the Defendants paragraph numbers.

            Ending with signed Statement of Truth.

            The reply should be returned to the court with the questionnaire and a copy of both sent to the Defendant.

            Comment


            • #7
              Much appreciated

              Comment


              • #8
                Hi all, I'm at the stage where both parties have sent DQs (I did not receive the DQ from the defendant). Some new information has come to light in that the defendant did not pay tax on the money that was paid to me. He deducted the tax but didn't pay the hmrc.

                Can I add the unpaid tax amount to my claim? Is it possible to amend at this stage? Is it possible to withdraw my claim and make a new claim? Just trying to figure out the best course of action?

                Comment


                • #9
                  You need to apply to the court. Please read CPR 17.4 (2) Probably a fee to pay.

                  When making a claim for unpaid wages at an employment tribunal, citizens advice recommend the claim should be gross to cover tax and N.I.

                  Did you contact citizens advice or consider an employment tribunal claim?

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    To clarify I am talking about construction work and CIS pay. I was a 'self-employed' contractor. I was paid for a few weeks of the job and have not been paid for the rest of the weeks. I have found out through a check that the 20% tax that was deducted from my pay was not paid to the HMRC. The claim I initiated against this individual was for the gross amount of the unpaid wages. I did not know until recently that the tax for the wages I was paid was not passed onto the HMRC.

                    The problem was that there were delays with contractors paying the lower down contractors due to various issues. So there was quite a bit of a time delay. Unfortunately I went to citizens advice after initiating my claim.

                    I was later advised I should have made the claim against the individual 'and anor' as opposed to just the individual. Could I change that too at this stage?

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Anor is a court term for Another
                      In your case Anor is the name of the LLC.
                      By not including the LLC in your claim you are asking the court to "pierce the veil"
                      Please google www.nolo.com piercing corporate veil and read the article
                      The court may decide to pierce the veil if the company has acted fraudulently or the director has mixed the company accounts with his own personal account. There are other reasons.
                      If you can prove any of the reasons with evidence you might have a case for the court to award damages against the director.

                      I am unsure about advice regarding:

                      1. Whether you should apply to the court to add or substitute the defendant, under CPR Part 19
                      2. Whether you cease your current claim, rewrite your PoC and start a new claim against just the LLC or the LLC and director jointly.
                      3. Whether you proceed with the current claim.

                      I am hoping another forum user with more legal knowledge and experience will help with advice.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        EXC any VIP members available to provide advice to OP?

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          It's not really my area I'm afraid.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            In light of the real difficulty piercing the corporate veil and without evidence of fraud or mixing bank accounts, this is what I would do. In the end it is your decision on the route forward.

                            I would abandon the present claim
                            I would check that I had concrete evidence in the form of authorised timesheets and proof these hours worked had not been paid for.
                            I would start a new claim against the LLC. After checking details with companies house.
                            In the event that I won my case I would check the procedures necessary to obtain the money owed if the LLC refused to pay.
                            I would make sure I was prepared to go all the way to a charging order on the director's property if necessary.

                            After writing the new PoC I would put the draft on this website with names redacted and ask for comments.

                            Comment

                            View our Terms and Conditions

                            LegalBeagles Group uses cookies to enhance your browsing experience and to create a secure and effective website. By using this website, you are consenting to such use.To find out more and learn how to manage cookies please read our Cookie and Privacy Policy.

                            If you would like to opt in, or out, of receiving news and marketing from LegalBeagles Group Ltd you can amend your settings at any time here.


                            If you would like to cancel your registration please Contact Us. We will delete your user details on request, however, any previously posted user content will remain on the site with your username removed and 'Guest' inserted.

                            Announcement

                            Collapse

                            Support LegalBeagles


                            Donate with PayPal button

                            LegalBeagles is a free forum, founded in May 2007, providing legal guidance and support to consumers and SME's across a range of legal areas.

                            See more
                            See less

                            Court Claim ?

                            Guides and Letters
                            Loading...



                            Search and Compare fixed fee legal services and find a solicitor near you.

                            Find a Law Firm


                            Working...
                            X