*** DISMISSED *** Small claims for stabling fees

[Stopbox]

Just glad it’s all over

[Stopbox]

We were just discussing what to do if she gets in contact again, and that was our conclusion tok

[jaguarsuk]

Claimant couldn’t provide a detailed schedule of payments or non payments, she relied on the handwritten schedules which the judge said didn’t relate to anything.

she also couldn’t figure out which was her statement or mine. Couldn’t find her own documents in her evidence bundle. It ended up being both the judge and myself helping her to find stuff.

she had no evidence of the alleged debt and he was questioning the value as there was inconsistencies in it, and even she couldn’t give an exact value.

i had to give my own evidence, judge wouldn’t allow husband to be Lay Representative.

he liked my detailed evidence, but was not happy about the handwritten note. However, the claimant started to call me names in the chambers which helped prove that she can be an aggressive person and he told her if she carried on it would affect his judgement.

when he gave his judgement, I had a huge smile on my face and asked if I could leave, which I did. The claimant was just sitting there staring at the judge in shock.

nothing was said about fee’s but I presume we pay our own, again more than happy with that

Yes if he ruled and allowed you to leave it will be parties to bear their own costs.

Just await the judgement through and file this all away.

If she gets in contact then it's back to the police and have them deal with her.

Well done speaking yourself and well done on an outcome you are happy with.

[Stopbox]

Claimant couldn’t provide a detailed schedule of payments or non payments, she relied on the handwritten schedules which the judge said didn’t relate to anything.

she also couldn’t figure out which was her statement or mine. Couldn’t find her own documents in her evidence bundle. It ended up being both the judge and myself helping her to find stuff.

she had no evidence of the alleged debt and he was questioning the value as there was inconsistencies in it, and even she couldn’t give an exact value.

i had to give my own evidence, judge wouldn’t allow husband to be Lay Representative.

he liked my detailed evidence, but was not happy about the handwritten note. However, the claimant started to call me names in the chambers which helped prove that she can be an aggressive person and he told her if she carried on it would affect his judgement.

when he gave his judgement, I had a huge smile on my face and asked if I could leave, which I did. The claimant was just sitting there staring at the judge in shock.

nothing was said about fee’s but I presume we pay our own, again more than happy with that

[jaguarsuk]

Both claim and counterclaim completely
dismissed, I’m happy with that

Excellent.

Let us know how she behaved, what was said etc. when you get a chance.

[GBExile]

Both claim and counterclaim completely
dismissed, I’m happy with that

Tally-ho

[Amethyst]

Great. Both parties to bear their own costs ?

Look forward to hearing the gory details later :~)

[Stopbox]

Both claim and counterclaim completely
dismissed, I’m happy with that

[jaguarsuk]

This is nail biting.

[Amethyst]

Fingers crossed for you.

[GBExile]

Waiting for judgement

Did the Judge read the statements beforehand?

[Stopbox]

Waiting for judgement

[MIKE770]

found the judges rarely read prior to hearing and play dumb?

[GBExile]

With regard to the hearing, am I right in believing that our 2hr slot will have some of the time taken up by the judge reading the statements and making a ruling and only some of the allotted time will be us in the chambers with him?

Whenever I have been to civil court the Judge has read the stuff before the hearing. Or they have done a very good job at appearing to have done so.

[Stopbox]

With regard to the hearing, am I right in believing that our 2hr slot will have some of the time taken up by the judge reading the statements and making a ruling and only some of the allotted time will be us in the chambers with him?