Kafka v Yorkshire Bank

[Kafka]

Re: Kafka v Yorkshire Bank

Is it same as Claires/Sue's ? If not then yes please.

A few minor variations, but I don't see anything significant.

[Amethyst]

Re: Kafka v Yorkshire Bank

Cool. Assume you are going back in with Stephen's defence to strike out appl ?

[Kafka]

Re: Kafka v Yorkshire Bank

Well I've not heard from the Court yet and they had not logged receipt but said the decision would be made on merit by a judge. They advised to wait till I hear.

[Amethyst]

Re: Kafka v Yorkshire Bank

I'd get in before then tbh. If you can get submissions in against the banks application before the judge looks at it he might not go the route of other courts and strike out ex parte. Also it would mean no requirement to pay the £75 to set aside any strike to defend the application.

I dont think u want the full PCF submissions, just a letter to the Judge to say that you are aware the banks applied for strike, you would like the opportunity to defend that application.

He'll probably come back and say you have to apply for amended parts and pay the £75 anyway but at least then he should consider the strike appl outside of the standard 'bank charges dealt with by supreme court so strike it out' thought process.

[Kafka]

Re: Kafka v Yorkshire Bank

Here is the set of documents that came with the strikeout application.

[Kafka]

Re: Kafka v Yorkshire Bank

and the last ones

[Amethyst]

Re: Kafka v Yorkshire Bank

Go on then, you'll have to point out the subtle differences.

[Kafka]

Re: Kafka v Yorkshire Bank

I am trying to identify the YB solicitors who have signed defence statements to the effect that the charges were genuine costs/pre-estimates.

Mine above was signed by Lyndsey Margaret Cullen and I would be pleased to hear if she still works there, where she is based and whether others have received defences signed by her in the same way.

I'd also like to know of any other examples of solicitors signing these defences at any time.

Many thanks

[CYNthesys]

Re: Kafka v Yorkshire Bank

This link for Scottish Law Society gives contact details for Lyndsey Cullen

http://www.lawsocietyofscotland.org....e-f3a1cad7b8aa

This link just seems to take you to the search facility, but it shows L Cullen as being with NAB, St Vincent's Place

[Kafka]

Re: Kafka v Yorkshire Bank

Have received this from Cardiff today. As many Welsh claims for bank charges were dumped in Cardiff, I suspect that everyone in Wales with a stayed YB claim had one of these for breakfast. At least they have offered a chance to resubmit, which I did not expect based on general performance at Cardiff regarding penalties.

[EXC]

Re: Kafka v Yorkshire Bank

It think it's a bit tacky of a court to quote what is case law from the Supreme Court 'press release' and ignore the judgment itself.

Especially when the press release specifically states that ''It does not form part of the reasons for the decision. The full judgment of the Court is the only authoritative document.''

[Kafka]

Re: Kafka v Yorkshire Bank

I agree, but its par for the course I think. This is a government agency that seems to be bereft of strategic leadership and where so many of the incumbents have indicated by their actions that they want nothing more than to get shot of the problem of charges claims. There seems to be no effective control machanism over them unless an individual has the money to take them on and risk losing a fortune.

[Celestine]

Re: Kafka v Yorkshire Bank

test