Re: Newlyn PLC-Claiming back excessive charges of PCN fine
Have they conveniently forgot to give the dates all these fees were incurred. Turning to the fees they have listed:
Council Debt - £202-00 - have to assume this is correct if the original was never paid or challenged
Closing Fee - £5-00 - what is this, is it listed within the Regulations - must be challenged
First Letter - £11-20 - seems correct - providing they can prove the letter was sent, ask for Certificate of Posting
Finance Check - £20-00 - what is this, is it listed within the Regulations - must be challenged
Enforcement Fee 1 - £175-00 - as far as I am aware there is no such thing - must be challenged
Levy Fee - £73-00 - according to my calculations it should be 28% on the first £200 = £56 + 5.5% on the balance = £1, a total of £57-00, therefore due a refund of £16-00. They cannot prove any of the extraneous fees are lawful. Total now owing £259-00.
Enforcement Fee 2 - £120-00 - as far as I am aware there is no such thing - must be challenged
Sch 1 Section 8 Fee - £35-00 - may be correct only if they have actually listed what they are claiming for
Subject Access Request - £8-33 - totally irrelevant as it submitted as separate request and paid for as such
VAT - £89-51 - needs reworking
Until such time they can prove they are entitled to the rest of the fees, in my opinion you are due a sizeable refund.
Have they conveniently forgot to give the dates all these fees were incurred. Turning to the fees they have listed:
Council Debt - £202-00 - have to assume this is correct if the original was never paid or challenged
Closing Fee - £5-00 - what is this, is it listed within the Regulations - must be challenged
First Letter - £11-20 - seems correct - providing they can prove the letter was sent, ask for Certificate of Posting
Finance Check - £20-00 - what is this, is it listed within the Regulations - must be challenged
Enforcement Fee 1 - £175-00 - as far as I am aware there is no such thing - must be challenged
Levy Fee - £73-00 - according to my calculations it should be 28% on the first £200 = £56 + 5.5% on the balance = £1, a total of £57-00, therefore due a refund of £16-00. They cannot prove any of the extraneous fees are lawful. Total now owing £259-00.
Enforcement Fee 2 - £120-00 - as far as I am aware there is no such thing - must be challenged
Sch 1 Section 8 Fee - £35-00 - may be correct only if they have actually listed what they are claiming for
Subject Access Request - £8-33 - totally irrelevant as it submitted as separate request and paid for as such
VAT - £89-51 - needs reworking
Until such time they can prove they are entitled to the rest of the fees, in my opinion you are due a sizeable refund.
Comment