• Welcome to the LegalBeagles Consumer and Legal Forum.
    Please Register to get the most out of the forum. Registration is free and only needs a username and email address.
    REGISTER
    Please do not post your full name, reference numbers or any identifiable details on the forum.

RLP "Letter to Claim" received—added customer points to my card, not stolen money.

Collapse
Loading...
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • RLP "Letter to Claim" received—added customer points to my card, not stolen money.

    Hi Forum Members,

    I started working for Boots in October 2024 and liked my job at the tills. I got familiar with how customers earn 3 points per 1£ on their boots card. I observed many people spending huge amount did not have boots card and and refused one when I offered them one (I really tried to convince them to get one). Being an international student from STEM background, I could not help myself from calculating how much on a daily basis the consumer lose out on points (as 100 points= £1 worth). Initially I wrote the numbers on back of the till paper but lost track of those. I thought it would be easier to add it to my own advantage card (first by taking receipt to other stores and getting them added to my card). By december, when the customer told me they dont have an advantage card, I manually entered my card number. I did not realise the severity of my actions. For me, it was a game to analyse how much people lose and how much reveue boots losses (I am from economics background). I did not spend any of those points and did not even keep a track of how many points have been added to my boots card. I was a temporary christmas employee so was gonna analyse it all after my contact ended on 31st December.

    On 19th December, on my regular shift, I was taken to the office and interrogated by an investigator about 183 such transactions on my employee id and was told i had about £163 pounds on my boots card in the form of points meaning I had collected 16300 points by taking customer receipts points (onlywhen they said they did not want a receipt) and by manually adding my card number if the customer said they have no boots card. I was told my boots card was frozen and I could anyway not use those points now. I had signed a contract that said points are considered as money at Boots, however, I had forgotten this and was just excited about my data analysis. Boots viewed my actions as gross misconduct and theft. The investigator showed my the CCTV clips of me typing my card number when customer did not give me their card, data showing the number of transaction and value of transactions and data showing how many receipts I have used to get points on my own card. Although I had not spent the amount, they viewed it as theft because I added it to my card.

    I immediately admitted my mistake and told them how it was just a math number game and basic analysis opportunity for me. It was not even exact figures, the analysis was mostly based on estimation and extrapolation of numbers. I told them how I didn't realise it was such a big deal. But they showed me all the evidence that they held convincing them of my misconduct and arranged for a second meeting i.e. disciplinary meeting with manager of other branch to decided if I should be dismissed or if they should give me a warning. On 23rd December, I had the meeting and immediately explained them my side of the story and they agreed I did not spent the points on that card. They decided to dismiss me and told me about civil recovery meaning costs of investigation and paying for the investigator's time or any value of product which I understood and left the premises.

    Now today on 18th January, I received a 'Letter before Claim' from RLP reiterating the cause of my dismissal and explicit breakdown of the outstanding amount which comes to £935 .02. The letter says "your actions have caused disruption to our client's business in detecting and investigating frauds and dealing with the consequences of your actions thereby claiming further costs for our client which is legally entitled to claim from you." The letter also mentions "Our client relies upon investigation files, data mining, transactional data, till, CCTV and evidence of personnel involved in the investigation to prove its claim" Follwing is the breakdown of their losses-

    Loss due to advantage card addition to the value of - £7.84
    Cost of Personnel Investigating, Detecting and Dealing with the matter- £474.38
    Administrative costs including mileage and travel - £84.4
    Security Costs Contribution- £365.4
    Total - £935.02

    The letter further says although the costs are as detailed their client is prepared to seek cotribution towards its investigative costs and lost goods in order to process its claim cost effectively, expediently and proportionately. "Our client is prepared to settle its claim in the sum of £257.84"

    Now, I do realise I made a grave mistake and accepted it immediately in front of the investigators and the disciplinary panel. And because there's no actual money involved it was not gonna be handled by the police. Now the situation is, I am an international student and will be flying back to my country in February 2025. I do intend to return in future if an employment opportunity in the UK presents itself. Hence, I do not want to risk any employment because of this case. My concerns are-

    1. I do not have time to wait for 2nd or 3rd followup letter and will not received the letters as I am moving to my country. Will they sue me for ignoring the letters? The very first letter is "Letter before Claim" and many forums said to ignore all letters except this one.
    2. Should I call them and offer to pay some portion of the £257.84? Because I am down to my last £212 in this country and can only pay upto £150. I literally never spend any points but am ready to pay the amount I added to my card.
    3. If I leave the country without settling this case and they decide to sue me, will I be arrested as and when I land in the UK?

    Please help.

    Thank you in advance
    Tags: None

  • #2
    Generally we advise to ignore RLP - read the many RLP threads on here.

    Your situation is different legally as most people asking advice here were in the store as customers and accused of shoplifting but you were an employee and are accused, essentially, of fraud against your employer. Employees have legal obligations to their employer that customers don't have.

    So let's see what others recommend.

    RLP threats are about a civil claim for compensation. You cannot be arrested for a civil claim or for alleged debt so no need to worry about that. The police are not involved so you are not facing any criminal investigation or prosecution for which you could be arrested
    All opinions expressed are based on my personal experience. I am not a lawyer and do not hold any legal qualifications.

    Comment


    • #3
      Originally posted by PallasAthena View Post

      So let's see what others recommend.
      I would advise absolutely ignore and don't pay anything. With the possible exception of the £7.84 Advantage card sum, all the other types of heads of claim were dismissed as non-recoverable in the Oxford test case in 2012 and nothing has changed since.

      Additionally, that they are prepared to accept 257 quid for a claim they value at £935 tells me they know they don't have a case.

      Comment


      • #4
        As stated by other members, the following costs are built into their business model.
        All employees are responsible for security (that's what their employee contract will say).
        Boots didn't 'hire' external personnel to investigate / interview you, so there are no costs,
        maybe the £7.84.


        'Cost of Personnel Investigating, Detecting and Dealing with the matter- £474.38
        Administrative costs including mileage and travel - £84.4
        Security Costs Contribution- £365.4'.


        1. I do not have time to wait for 2nd or 3rd followup letter and will not received the letters as I am moving to my country. Will they sue me for ignoring the letters? The very first letter is "Letter before Claim" and many forums said to ignore all letters except this one.

        You won't receive a Letter Before Claim. Just speculative invoices with baseless numbers.

        2. Should I call them and offer to pay some portion of the £257.84? Because I am down to my last £212 in this country and can only pay upto £150. I literally never spend any points but am ready to pay the amount I added to my card.

        Only communicate with them in writing, the only figure that might be genuine is £7.84, but again that might be wrong.

        3. If I leave the country without settling this case and they decide to sue me, will I be arrested as and when I land in the UK?

        You will not be arrested or sued.

        Just to add, technology would have 'flagged' up your activities weeks and weeks before they confronted you for the first time.





        Comment


        • #5
          Thank you for your valued input.
          @PallasAthena I understand employees have legal obligations to their employers but will boots drag me to court for ignoring these letters?

          @EXC I am willing to repay the 7 quid sum but do I pay it through RLP? Because they will know I have received the letters read it and decided to pay merely £7.84. Does 'They don't have a case' mean Boots wont sue me for this recovery? because the investigator and disciplinary interrogator both asked me to look out for civil recovery email. Although I did ask them when it was due as I was leaving the country soon.

          @echat11

          '
          You won't receive a Letter Before Claim. Just speculative invoices with baseless numbers'

          But the letter I received yesterday did read as 'Letter before Claim'. Or is 'letter before claim' a different legal document altogether?

          Only communicate with them in writing, the only figure that might be genuine is £7.84, but again that might be wrong.

          I was thinking of mailing them. But I do not know how to state that I can pay up only £7.84. Also they will know I have got their mail, nullifying the advice of ignoring their threats. £7.84 might be made up cost too. I suspected this as I have never touched any point on my card. I did not even know how much I have collected. But for the inconvenience i caused them I am willing to pay at least £7.84.

          You will not be arrested or sued.

          That is a relief. As mentioned before, I am an international student and although am now returning to my country, if an employment opportunity presents I might come back and work in the UK after a few years. Will non-payment of this sum be flagged on my profile? Does it affect my credit score? Can prospective employers access this file or documents confirming I have failed to make this payment? How will this £257 claim affect my future employment and skilled worker visa approval in the UK?

          Just to add, technology would have 'flagged' up your activities weeks and weeks before they confronted you for the first time.

          Yeah!!! thats what I thought too. But I am unsure how does this help my case?

          Once again , Thank you forum members for your responses.

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by ash279770 View Post
            @EXC I am willing to repay the 7 quid sum but do I pay it through RLP? Because they will know I have received the letters read it and decided to pay merely £7.84. Does 'They don't have a case' mean Boots wont sue me for this recovery? because the investigator and disciplinary interrogator both asked me to look out for civil recovery email. Although I did ask them when it was due as I was leaving the country soon.
            No don't pay them anything, it'll only encourage them to keep sending you letters for more. Boots won't sue you.

            They're just doing what they always do - trying to scare you into paying them money. Don't allow them to.

            Comment


            • #7

              a) 'You won't receive a Letter Before Claim. Just speculative invoices with baseless numbers'

              But the letter I received yesterday did read as 'Letter before Claim'. Or is 'letter before claim' a different legal document altogether?

              They may of sent one titled 'Letter Before Action', the thing is they won't act on it (it's just still an 'speculative invoice'), as some years ago they lost a case of employee theft because of some of the same facts in your case, i.e. security, employee costs etc.

              b) Only communicate with them in writing, the only figure that might be genuine is £7.84, but again that might be wrong.

              I was thinking of mailing them. But I do not know how to state that I can pay up only £7.84. Also they will know I have got their mail, nullifying the advice of ignoring their threats. £7.84 might be made up cost too. I suspected this as I have never touched any point on my card. I did not even know how much I have collected. But for the inconvenience i caused them I am willing to pay at least £7.84.

              If you believe you owe nothing, then do nothing.

              c) You will not be arrested or sued.

              That is a relief. As mentioned before, I am an international student and although am now returning to my country, if an employment opportunity presents I might come back and work in the UK after a few years. Will non-payment of this sum be flagged on my profile? Does it affect my credit score? Can prospective employers access this file or documents confirming I have failed to make this payment? How will this £257 claim affect my future employment and skilled worker visa approval in the UK?

              They are pointless questions, a valid question is, will Boots give you a reference? What sort of reference will it be?

              d) Just to add, technology would have 'flagged' up your activities weeks and weeks before they confronted you for the first time.

              Yeah!!! thats what I thought too. But I am unsure how does this help my case?

              It was an extra point of no relevance. You are overthinking this.

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by ash279770 View Post
                Will non-payment of this sum be flagged on my profile? Does it affect my credit score? Can prospective employers access this file or documents confirming I have failed to make this payment? How will this £257 claim affect my future employment and skilled worker visa approval in the UK?
                There is no such thing as your "profile" so there nothing for future employers to access. Nothing will be flagged anywhere unless you were actually taken to court and got a court judgement against you. So RLP's demands will never be known by anyone UNLESS Boots actually took you to court and got a court judgement against you. Neither can anything RLP does affect your credit score. But as said before this isn't going to happen.

                Because RLP have no legal authority to make you pay this it would be illegal for RLP to disclose their demands for money to anybody. They would likely be guilty of ana offence under the Data ProtectionAct if they did so.

                All opinions expressed are based on my personal experience. I am not a lawyer and do not hold any legal qualifications.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Thank you so much for your responses. I was up all night becuase of the letter but upon reading people's experiences and advise I have decided to simply ignore the letter. Hopefully nothing bad comes out of this.

                  Comment

                  View our Terms and Conditions

                  LegalBeagles Group uses cookies to enhance your browsing experience and to create a secure and effective website. By using this website, you are consenting to such use.To find out more and learn how to manage cookies please read our Cookie and Privacy Policy.

                  If you would like to opt in, or out, of receiving news and marketing from LegalBeagles Group Ltd you can amend your settings at any time here.


                  If you would like to cancel your registration please Contact Us. We will delete your user details on request, however, any previously posted user content will remain on the site with your username removed and 'Guest' inserted.
                  Working...
                  X